The Last Jedi, Star Wars Episode VIII, is a movie that seems to have more controversy about it than any other recent movie. Some people love it, some people hate it, and everyone has an opinion. Short review? See it for yourself.
Longer version: The Last Jedi is a movie which is focused upon building (or rebuilding) the Star Wars universe. On the one hand, TLJ is Star Wars, in a way that the prequels weren’t. It’s fun, it’s humorous, and it tells a story of good versus evil. Plus there’s magic space wizardry and exploding space ships.
On the other hand, it isn’t a movie without flaws, or without messages of cynicism. There are vast swathes of the movie that could have been cut out or streamlined. There are militarily stupid decisions made, that if they were made in the real world, people would face serious criminal charges. There’s a lot of humor, but some of that humor is cutting, to the point of offending those who held the original movies (and the expanded universe) close to their hearts.
But it is a new story. This isn’t a repeat of things that have come before. This is the start of something new. And in a lot of ways, that’s the problem that many people have with the movie. There were decisions made with the story structure and plot that suggest the franchise is moving on. This isn’t about the original series and original characters, it’s about the greater universe.
On the third hand, there were decisions made in the new story structure that were… too safe. There were some, potentially, very powerfully emotional scenes, and multiple times the writers/directors pulled back from the full delivery of those scenes. They shied away from doing the hard things, they kill off swathes of faceless people we care little about (to the point of absurdity), yet there were several scenes where named characters should have died… yet they didn’t.
Overall, I enjoyed the movie. It was fun and (despite the many faults) it was still Star Wars. It had the spirit, the character, of a long, long time ago in a galaxy far, far away. I will say that walking out of the theater, I really had enjoyed the experience, it was only after thinking about various scenes and story elements that I began to notice the flaws. I recommend seeing it and developing your own opinion.